TechHR
ex
L&D
UNPLUGGED
Sphere
About Us • Contact Us
People Matters ANZ
People Matters Logo
Login / Signup
People Matters Logo
Login / Signup
  • Current
  • Top Stories
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Research
  • Events
  • Videos
  • Webinars
  • Podcast

© Copyright People Matters Media Pte. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

 

 

  • HotTopic
    HR Folk Talk FutureProofHR
  • Strategy
    Leadership Csuite StrategicHR EmployeeRelations BigInterview
  • Recruitment
    Employer Branding Appointments Permanent Hiring Recruitment
  • Performance
    Skilling PerformanceMgmt Compensation Benefits L&D Employee Engagement
  • Culture
    Culture Life@Work Diversity Watercooler SheMatters
  • Tech
    Technology HR Technology Funding & Investment Startups Metaverse
  • About Us
  • Advertise with us
  • Become a sponsor
  • Contact Us
  • Feedback
  • Write For Us

Follow us:

Privacy Policy • Terms of Use

© Copyright People Matters Media Pte. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

People Matters Logo
  • Current
  • Top Stories
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Research
  • Events
  • Videos
  • Webinars
  • Podcast
Login / Signup

Categories:

  • HotTopic
    HR Folk Talk FutureProofHR
  • Strategy
    Leadership Csuite StrategicHR EmployeeRelations BigInterview
  • Recruitment
    Employer Branding Appointments Permanent Hiring Recruitment
  • Performance
    Skilling PerformanceMgmt Compensation Benefits L&D Employee Engagement
  • Culture
    Culture Life@Work Diversity Watercooler SheMatters
  • Tech
    Technology HR Technology Funding & Investment Startups Metaverse
Under-representation of women in leadership: The need for cultural change action

Story • 1st Mar 2022 • 3 Min Read

Under-representation of women in leadership: The need for cultural change action

Leadership#GuestArticle#BreaktheBias

Author: Dr Pete Harpum Dr Pete Harpum
13.2K Reads
Where women are in top leadership positions, businesses have: improved financial performance; strengthened organisational climates; increased corporate social responsibility and reputation

“Gender appears to be at the forefront of the global humanitarian agenda”. So wrote the editors of the esteemed Academy of Management Journal in 2015, when reviewing nearly sixty years of research on gender issues in management. Despite setbacks to women’s rights around the world since the date of that paper, we believe that gender equality in business, and specifically leadership, is still one of the dominant themes in organisational development (along with diversity in general). If it isn’t dominant in your organisation, it surely should be.

Ratios of women in senior leadership across regions are reported at: Africa 38%; Eastern Europe 35%; Latin America 33%; European Union 30%; North America 29%; and Asia Pacific 27%. A sobering set of statistics. Globally, the ratio of women leaders going up the ladder decreases: support staff 47%; professionals 42%; Managers 37%; senior managers 29%; executives 23%. The very low rates of women CEOs before the COVID-19 pandemic has become even lower, now at 5%. All this is despite the evidence that higher performing organisations have higher ratios of women to men in leadership roles. (So much for capitalism optimising performance.)

Various theories on the lack of women leaders have developed over the years, including individual-centred factors such as a comparative lack of confidence in women compared to men, lack of willingness to self-promote, and reluctance to give honest assessments of their performance. More organisation-centric perspectives suggest that women receive insufficient development, gender differences between men and women play a role, and anti-woman bias predicates against progression. Many of these factors are created by, or reinforced through, systemic and process aspects of organisations. Not surprising, since the organisations themselves are reflective of the wider societies in which they exist – a jumble of systems and processes of human life. Michelle Bligh and Ai Ito conceptualise this as the Male Competitive Model. They say that “cross-culturally, most modern organisations have been developed and led by men in a way that has been adapted to their values and assumptions in predominantly gender-segregated societies”.

Figure 1 shows how these influences affect the under-representation of women in leadership. Amy Diehl and Leanne Dzubinski have identified twenty seven gender-based leadership barriers at different levels of society.

Figure 1: Sociocultural and organisational systems affecting the under-representation of women leaders (Michelle Bligh & Ai Ito, in the Handbook of research on gender and leadership, 2017, page 289)

Perhaps a useful starting point for organisational leaders, is to reflect on findings from two recent business performance reports. Where women are in top leadership positions, businesses have: improved financial performance;  strengthened organisational climates; increased corporate social responsibility and reputation; talent leveraged better; and innovation and collective intelligence are enhanced. The ethical and moral case for equal ratios of women and men in leadership is indisputable – so is the business case.

The next step is to acknowledge and accept that culturally-driven norms will only change when those norms are challenged and cultural change is defined, planned for, and enacted. Not simply for the business performance improvements it brings, but quite clearly, also, for ethical and moral reasons. Lack of women leaders is culturally-driven and needs cultural change action to bring more and more women leaders to the upper echelons of organisations. This leads, inexorably, to such change actions as women-only leadership development, women mentors for (future) women leaders, and revised metrics for performance (e.g. metrics that acknowledge the ‘soft’ power that women deploy to great effect, but which is not currently measured).

The motivating forces for this change must include men – they currently have most leadership roles, from which they can support this work. Men must join with and fully support women when they initiate the work to bring equality for women leaders. There is even greater emphasis on this now as the world emerges slowly from the COVID-19 pandemic and we find not more, but fewer women in senior leadership roles. 

We finish off this article with a list of cultural change actions that organisations can work with, Figure 2, again by Michelle Bligh and Ai Ito. What we must also ask is: what is needed to bring about these changes? The answer is for senior leaders to have the vision, courage, and personal commitment to drive cultural change programs into their organisations. This means personally sponsoring prioritised, fully funded, fully resourced change programs to achieve equality for women at all levels of leadership. It also means being prepared to be seen, in wider society, to be passionate and engaged in the issue of equality for women.

Figure 2: Solutions for changing organisational systems and practices (source: Michelle Bligh & Ai Ito, in the Handbook of research on gender and leadership, 2017, page 298.)

Read More

Did you find this article helpful?


You Might Also Like

Did Microsoft's leadership let Skype crumble?

STORY • 6th May 2025 • 3 Min Read

Did Microsoft's leadership let Skype crumble?

LeadershipTechnologyBusiness#HRTech#HRCommunity
The trust factor: What leaders should know

STORY • 29th Apr 2025 • 5 Min Read

The trust factor: What leaders should know

LeadershipExecutive EducationTalent Management
Leading the way to a sustainable tomorrow

STORY • 22nd Apr 2025 • 3 Min Read

Leading the way to a sustainable tomorrow

Leadership#ESG#WorldEarthDay
NEXT STORY: Reimagine the role of HR with Dr Dave Ulrich

Trending Stories

  • design-thinking-hr

    Skype is dead: Did Microsoft's leadership let a billion-doll...

  • design-thinking-hr

    Keeping the C-suite in the C-suite - how do we reduce execut...

  • design-thinking-hr

    Return to office: the legalities

  • design-thinking-hr

    The trust factor: Why modern leaders can’t afford to overl...

People Matters Logo

Follow us:

Join our mailing list:

By clicking “Subscribe” button above, you are accepting our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Company:

  • About Us
  • Advertise with us
  • Become a sponsor
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Contact:

  • Contact Us
  • Feedback
  • Write For Us

© Copyright People Matters Media Pte. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Get the latest Articles, Insight, News & Trends from the world of Talent & Work. Subscribe now!
People Matters Logo

Welcome Back!

or

Enter your registered email address to login

Not a user yet? Lets get you signed up!

A 5 digit OTP has been sent to your email address.

This is so we know it's you. Haven't received it yet? Resend the email or then change your email ID.

People Matters Logo

Welcome! Let's get you signed up...

Starting with the absolulte basics.

Already a user? Go ahead and login!

A 5 digit OTP has been sent to your email address.

This is so we know it's you. Haven't received it yet? Resend the email or then change your email ID.

Let's get to know you better

We'll never share your details with anyone, pinky swear.

And lastly...

Your official designation and company name.