Candidate screening: not all that glitters is gold

"Not all that glitters is gold" might be the phrase that sums up what sometimes happens with job candidates who seemed ideal but who, once hired, turn out to be much less than expected.

Hiring the right candidate for a job is a critical decision for any organisation, yet many employers still struggle to get it right. Despite meticulous screening processes and interviews, mismatches between candidates and job roles occur frequently, leading to wasted time and resources, and potential damage to company culture and performance. So, why do these errors persist, and what deceptive factors lead employers astray?

Hiring mistakes

First and foremost, it's essential to understand the financial implications of hiring mistakes. According to research conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), the cost of a bad hire can range from 50% to several times the employee's annual salary, factoring in recruitment expenses, training costs, lost productivity, and potential severance packages. For small businesses, in particular, these costs can be disproportionately burdensome, impacting profitability and growth.

READ MORE | The value of skills-first hiring

To avoid these common pitfalls, experts emphasise the importance of implementing robust hiring practices grounded in data and objective evaluation.

Julie Zhuo, author and former Vice President of Product Design at Facebook, advocates for structured interviews and standardised assessment criteria to minimise bias and ensure consistency across candidates.

Richard Branson, founder of the Virgin Group, emphasises the value of cultural fit and alignment with company values, stating, "Skills can be taught, personality cannot."

And Laszlo Bock, CEO of Humu and former Senior Vice President of People Operations at Google, underscores the importance of data-driven decision-making in hiring, urging employers to leverage analytics and predictive models to accurately identify top talent.

Several factors contribute to the misalignment between candidates and job roles, often leading employers astray:

Overemphasis on technical skills

While technical skills are undoubtedly essential for certain roles, focusing solely on technical proficiency can be misleading. Employers may overlook candidates with strong soft skills, such as communication, teamwork, and adaptability, which are often crucial for long-term success and cultural fit within the organisation.

The 'halo' effect

The halo effect occurs when positive impressions in one area influence perceptions in other areas. For example, a candidate with an impressive CV or charismatic personality may receive favourable evaluations despite lacking critical job-related skills or experience. Employers must remain vigilant to avoid being swayed by superficial attributes that may not accurately reflect a candidate's suitability for the role.

Confirmation bias

Human beings naturally seek information that confirms their existing beliefs or preferences, leading to confirmation bias in the hiring process. Employers may unconsciously favour candidates who align with their preconceived notions or preferences, overlooking potentially better-suited candidates who challenge their assumptions.

READ MORE | Job search 101: the power of networking

Factors that mislead hiring managers

Hiring mistakes are costly and pervasive, but not inevitable. By acknowledging the deceptive factors that lead employers astray and embracing evidence-based hiring practices, organisations can mitigate risks, attract the right talent, and foster a culture of excellence that drives long-term success.

According to an article published by LinkedIn Talent Solutions, finding the perfect fit for a vacant position can be a daunting task. However, by designing the ideal candidate profile beforehand, companies can streamline the hiring process, identify top-notch professionals, and ultimately make better hiring decisions based on data-driven insights.

LinkedIn Talent Solutions has designed a four-step strategy to fine-tune the decision when hiring new talent for a business. According to the publication, these are the steps to follow:

1. Coordinate with the Hiring Team: Collaboration is key when it comes to designing the ideal candidate profile. Before diving into the process, ensure alignment among all stakeholders involved in the hiring process. This includes HR professionals, hiring managers, department heads, and any other relevant parties. By gathering input from diverse perspectives, a company can create a comprehensive profile that encompasses the skills, experience, and qualities essential for success in the role.

2. Interview Top Employees: One of the most effective ways to identify the key attributes of an ideal candidate is by interviewing your top-performing employees. These individuals can provide valuable insights into the qualities that contribute to success within the organisation. Ask them about the skills, traits, and behaviours they believe are crucial for excelling in their roles. By leveraging the firsthand experiences of your best employees, a company can ensure that the candidate profile is grounded in real-world success factors.

3. Create the Ideal Profile: Armed with insights from the team and top employees, it's time to craft the ideal candidate profile. Start by outlining the essential qualifications, including educational background, technical skills, and industry-specific expertise required for the role. Additionally, consider soft skills such as communication abilities, problem-solving aptitude, and cultural fit with the organisation. By balancing both hard and soft skills, a company can create a holistic profile that captures the full spectrum of qualities necessary for success.

4. Review the Profile with Stakeholders: Before finalising the candidate profile, it's essential to review it with all relevant stakeholders. This includes not only the hiring team but also department heads, executives, and other individuals who will be impacted by the hiring decision. Solicit feedback and input to ensure that the profile accurately reflects the needs and priorities of the organisation. By gaining buy-in from all stakeholders, a company can increase the likelihood of finding the right candidate who aligns with the company's values and goals.

Designing the ideal candidate profile is a crucial step in the hiring process that can significantly enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of your recruitment efforts. Experts suggest following these four steps—coordinating with the hiring team, interviewing top employees, creating the ideal profile, and reviewing it with stakeholders—so you can streamline your hiring process, attract top talent, and make informed hiring decisions that drive success for your organisation.