Stop playing the 'blame game'! How to build a culture of accountability

In the aftermath of an accident, it's an instinctive reaction for leaders and team members to search for someone to blame when a project falters.

Perhaps it serves as a defense mechanism, allowing us to evade responsibility or shield ourselves from the discomfort of acknowledging our own mistakes.

Yet, this blame culture spawns toxic environments and behaviours, particularly within the realm of work. It corrodes relationships, stifles creativity, and hampers initiative, according to numerous studies.

The end result? People and teams unwilling to take risks, thus impeding their professional growth and depriving them of the opportunity to learn from their missteps.

When we attribute our problems solely to others, we absolve ourselves of any need for change. Consequently, blame hampers collaboration, stifles creativity, inhibits learning, and engenders conflict.

As far back as 1970, psychologist and researcher John Gottman identified criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling as the most destructive behaviours in relationships. Their detrimental impact extends beyond personal connections to our work environments.

READ MORE | Understanding the priorities of your Gen Z colleague

One study illuminates our brain's penchant for fixating on negative experiences over positive ones, with the former leaving a more profound imprint in our memories. The authors propose that good can only counterbalance bad through sheer numbers. In fact, the five-to-one ratio, discovered by Gottman, applies just as aptly to our present-day workplaces.

Pablo Gonzáles Cuellar, an Occupational Health, Safety, and Process Specialist, delineates three significant consequences of a blame culture within an organisation:

1. Concealment of errors

2. When a culture of blame permeates an organisation, individuals are prone to concealing errors and incidents, fearing retribution. This hampers the early identification of problems and the implementation of necessary corrective measures.

3. Lack of transparency and learning

4. In a blame culture, employees refrain from admitting mistakes or sharing information about incidents, fearing isolation or punishment. Consequently, transparency within the organisation suffers, impeding collective learning. Furthermore, a culture that fails to value and respect its employees cultivates a toxic work environment, eroding commitment to the organisation.

5. Lack of trust and collaboration

6. Blame erodes trust among colleagues and between staff members and management. When individuals fear being scapegoated or given a penalty, they are less inclined to communicate openly and honestly. This, in turn, hinders collaboration, effective communication, and cohesive teamwork.

READ MORE | What's hurting your team productivity?

To combat the insidious nature of blame culture, Louis Carter, CEO and Founder at Most Loved Workplace® and Best Practice Institute, emphasises the detrimental impact it has on productivity and quality within an organisation.

Blame culture disrupts the social fabric of the workplace, fostering divisions and eroding trust. Instead of nurturing collaboration, creativity, and support, blame and excuses render employees vulnerable and detached from their work.

Carter presents three strategies to counteract blame culture:

1. Raise awareness about the effects of blame and excuses

2. By highlighting the personal toll of these behaviours, rather than solely focusing on their impact on productivity or company culture, we can effectively bring about change. Blame and excuses trigger negative thought patterns, such as powerlessness, pessimism, helplessness, and anger.

3. Cease the cycle of blaming yourself and others

4. Blame and excuses, as Carter explains, are nothing more than habits that permeate an entire company culture. To break these habits, we must halt the patterns that sustain them. According to Psychology Today, habits are simply patterns of behavior, and breaking them requires interrupting the cycle.

5. Implement mechanisms to ensure accountability

6. A culture of responsibility should be ingrained as a habitual practice, wherein each individual takes personal accountability and holds their peers to the same standard. Leadership and managers play a crucial role in this endeavour by implementing follow-up strategies, modelling the desired behaviour, and providing guidance.

By cultivating a blame-free environment, organisations can foster healthier, more productive workplaces that nurture growth, creativity, and collaboration. Let us recognise the destructiveness of blame culture and commit to building a culture of accountability and trust.